
But, BOTD is vintage Scorsese. In a review of the film, Chicago Sun Times movie critic Roger Ebert echoes an accurate claim about Scorsese pictures: “you can watch them with the sound off, or with a picture and no sound.” Truer words have not been spoken. Scorsese’s manic attention to the sound editing and his artistic approach to each shot make all of his films so dense that they drip with atmosphere. His name and pull in Hollywood have afforded him the opportunity to offer his treatment to period stories (The Aviator and Gangs of New York), but his style was created with Mean Streets, perfected for an Oscar in The Departed, and are on full display in BOTD.
Dead is Scorsese’s most recent, modern day, New York story to date and his vision of this New York (or more specifically, Hell’s Kitchen) is one of darkly despair. The film embodies, with great help from its sound, elements from a variety of genres. The voice-over work by star Nicholas Cage and the bluesy Van Morrison number (TB Sheets) suggests a noir-like quality, while other scenes – using a haunting original score – play almost like a horror film. But, overall this is a stylized film about Frank Pierce’s (Cage) troubled journey as he grapples with the sufferings and tensions of being the front line response in a city where horrendous scenes never end.
Scorsese again teams with screenwriter/director Paul Schrader to create Joe Connelly’s novel of the same name. The themes from the book seem to have resonated with Scorsese: that the city doesn’t discriminate when it comes to who it swallows and that in this community – rich with derelicts – Paramedics serve with a simultaneous disgust and sense of duty for their patients. Much like their previous collaboration, Taxi Driver, BOTD lacks a standard or structured plot but it doesn’t need it.
This story is all about sense of place, and nobody does it better than Scorsese. He needs only to provide us with an authentic look into the average shift of an EMS worker in NYC to create the sense of disorientation involved in the endless and inevitable horrors that the city reveals nightly.
Pierce is being haunted by the faces (mainly a young teen named Rose) of people he failed to save. Ironically as he explains this, his first call brings him to a cardiac case that is pronounced dead, but, due to Pierce’s treatment, survives to earn a trip to a municipal hospital ER where the waiting room plays more like a gen pop jail cell than anything else. This case also introduces Pierce (and the audience) to Mary (played by Patricia Arquette), daughter of the heart attack victim. Their resulting relationship does not evolve into a romantic endeavor, but rather illustrates their mutual desire to have somebody to lean on as they navigate the hostile waters of Hell’s Kitchen.
I know Scorsese loves NYC, but in his attempt to capture the true grit and griminess of this 3rd shift world, he inadvertently glamorizes it and makes it look beautiful. His use of wet buildings, smoky streets, shadowy alleys, dungy ‘take out’ restaurants are so well done that you get the same feeling of those who occupy these quarters: that there is beauty in this chaos. It once again invokes that noir quality. Scorsese also makes good use of the living spaces and interiors of his characters. One apartment, aptly named the Oasis, has a hidden level of comfort for those who spend their time there. Scorsese excels in illustrating just how cramped and desolate some of these quarters can be, but given still, how they serve as a refuge to the hostility just outside their doors.
Along with Scorsese’s beautiful craftwork comes the great performances he expels from Ving Rhames, John Goodman, Tom Sizemore, Cage and Arquette. All of them are in top form hitting their various personalities pitch point. Pierce’s partners seem to be a base of sanity for his mental meanderings as well as a thorn in his side with each one crazier than the next.
Goodman plays Larry who is a blue collar blueprint of a municipal worker gaming his way up the pay and title scale hoping “to pass his captain’s exam” and secure a better pay and benefits for his family.
Rhames’ Marcus understands the spiritual dilemma Pierce is struggling with, but his own antics generally cloud his theological revelations.
Finally, Sizemore’s Tom is just plain crazy and reminds Pierce constantly of their old days together. Days Pierce would just as soon forget as Tom represents the dangers a failing and stagnant career as an EMS worker can offer.
Hidden in all of these great performances are several HBO character actors including a dying Michael Williams (Omar), a drugged up and eventually murdered Sonja Sohn (Kima), a caring nurse (Aida Turturro aka Janice Soprano) and finally a touching performance from Arthur J. Nascarella (Sopranos crew member Carlo Gervasi) who has a show stealing scene as Frank’s passive captain: “I promise. I’m going to fire you tomorrow.”
But the show stealer might be the performance logged by Latin music artist Marc Anthony. I had no clue who he was the first time I saw this picture and was impressed. After being introduced to his persona and ensuing music fame I was amazed that I still was won over by his work on BOTD.
All of the actors are on board and they need to be buckled in as Scorsese propels them through this frantic paced story which is matched only by his style. It’s been rumored that he schedules at least a year to edit his films with long time collaborator Thelma Schoonmaker and it isn’t disproved when you see the thousands of shots he uses to create this picture. The material from Connolly seems as scrambled as the visuals, but as mentioned before, the story doesn’t need to conclude a plot. It’s a sense of place. Hell’s Kitchen: Late 90’s.
